ICE Can’t Enter Rikers for Now, Judge Rules
On April 21, 2025, New York State Supreme Court Judge Mary Rosado issued a temporary restraining order halting Mayor Eric Adams' plan to permit U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents to operate within the Rikers Island jail complex. This decision responds to a lawsuit filed by the New York City Council, which alleges that the mayor's executive order facilitating ICE's return to Rikers was part of a quid pro quo arrangement with the Trump administration to dismiss federal corruption charges against him. Gothamist+10AP News+10Jamaica Gleaner+10
Background
In 2014, New York City enacted sanctuary city laws that effectively barred ICE from operating within Rikers Island, aiming to protect undocumented immigrants from federal immigration enforcement. However, Mayor Adams recently signed an executive order, through Deputy Mayor Randy Mastro, allowing ICE to reestablish an office at Rikers. The administration asserts that ICE's presence would be limited to assisting in criminal investigations, such as those related to gangs and drug trafficking, and would not involve civil immigration enforcement. AP News+3AP News+3Jamaica Gleaner+3Jamaica Gleaner+9AP News+9POLITICO+9
Legal Challenge
The City Council's lawsuit contends that Mayor Adams' executive order violates the city's sanctuary policies and was improperly authorized. They argue that the delegation of authority to Deputy Mayor Mastro was unlawful and that the move compromises the city's commitment to protecting immigrant communities. Furthermore, the Council alleges that the timing of the executive order, following the dismissal of federal charges against Adams, suggests a corrupt bargain with the Trump administration. POLITICO+11POLITICO+11AP News+11Gothamist+7THE CITY - NYC News+7ABC News+7Fox News+4AP News+4AP News+4
Temporary Restraining Order
Judge Rosado's order prohibits the city from negotiating, signing, or implementing any agreement with the federal government regarding ICE's presence at Rikers until a hearing scheduled for April 25. This pause allows the court to consider the merits of the City Council's lawsuit and determine the legality of the executive order. Yahoo+6AP News+6ABC News+6
Political Implications
The controversy has significant political ramifications. Mayor Adams, a Democrat, faces criticism from within his party for aligning with the Trump administration on immigration enforcement. City Council Speaker Adrienne Adams, a mayoral challenger, has been vocal in opposing the executive order, framing it as a betrayal of New York City's values and a threat to immigrant communities. Fox News+2POLITICO+2AP News+2Fox News+3ABC News+3Jamaica Gleaner+3POLITICO+5AP News+5AP News+5
Conclusion
The court's intervention underscores the ongoing tension between federal immigration policies and local sanctuary laws. As the April 25 hearing approaches, the outcome will likely have lasting effects on the city's approach to immigration enforcement and the balance of power between the mayor's office and the City Council.
No comments